You are viewing the site in preview mode

Skip to main content

Table 2 Facilitators and challenges in working with UYRs

From: Challenges and facilitators in treating unaccompanied young refugees with posttraumatic stress disorder in a dissemination trial: a qualitative study with psychotherapists

Facilitators

Frequency

Challenges

Frequency

Project-related

 

Project-related

 
  

 No challengesb

8 (44.4%)

Case consultationsa

   

  General effectiveness

12 (60.0%)

  

  Group-based learning

8 (40.0%)

  

  Increases adherence

7 (35.0%)

  

  Enables flexibility within fidelity

5 (25.0%)

  

  Reflecting about patient

5 (25.0%)

  

  Supervising person as competent contact person

4 (20.0%)

  

TF-CBT Workshopa

   

  General effectiveness

4 (20.0%)

  

  Conveys important knowledge

4 (20.0%)

  

  Structure of the workshop

2 (10.0%)

  

Both case consultations and workshopa

5 (25.0%)

  

Materiala

 

Materialb

 

  General availability of material

12 (60.0%)

  Material not adequate

3 (15.0%)

  Availability of worksheets

5 (25.0%)

  

  Availability of translated materials

5 (25.0%)

  

German TF-CBT Weba

 

German TF-CBT Webb

 

  General effectiveness

4 (20.0%)

  Too extensive

2 (10.0%)

  Video examples

3 (15.0%)

  

  Repeated use possible

2 (10.0%)

  

  Flexibility

2 (10.0%)

  

Manualized and evidence-based treatmenta

9 (45.0%)

Documentationb

7 (35.0%)

Provision/Funding of interpretersa

8 (40.0%)

Lacking information on organizational aspectsb

4 (20.0%)

Financial compensation for psychotherapistsa

8 (40.0%)

Knowledge decayb

2 (10.0%)

Preparation and Initiation of treatmenta

7 (35.0%)

  

Availability of contact personsa

5 (25.0%)

  

Digital implementationa

3 (15.0%)

  

Structural

 

Structural

 

CYWS facility aspectsc

 

CYWS facility aspectsa

 

  Supporting/accompanying the treatment sessions

7 (38.9%)

  Lacking clear primary clearly responsible caregiver

7 (35.0%)

  High treatment compliance from caregivers/facility

8 (44.4%)

  Lacking therapy compliance from caregivers/facility

3 (15.0%)

  Supportive caregivers in everyday life

5 (27.8%)

  Caregiver-imposed outcome pressure

2 (10.0%)

  Collaboration and exchange between caregivers and psychotherapist

3 (16.7%)

  Lacking caregiver/conjoint sessions

4 (20.0%)

  Knowledge about PTSD/psychotherapy

2 (11.1%)

  Lacking knowledge about PTSD/psychotherapy

3 (15.0%)

  Facilitating transportationc

2 (11.1%)

  Logistical access issues

4 (20.0%)

Availability of interpreters c

9 (50%)

Long distance between facility & psychotherapy a

7 (35.0%)

Use of supplemental materialsc

4 (22.2%)

Difficult time coordinationa

8 (40.0%)

Location of the practicec

2 (11.1%)

Increased efforta

6 (30.0%)

  

Technical issuesa

4 (20.0%)

  

Lacking clear responsibility from Youth Welfare Officea

4 (20.0%)

  

Unreliability of public transportationa

2 (10.0%)

Personal

 

Personal

 

Good therapeutic allianced

6 (46.2%)

  

Openness to treat UYRsd

3 (23.1%)

  

Patient-related

 

Patient-related

 

Treatment readinesse

6 (54.5%)

Lacking treatment readinessf

5 (33.3%)

Language proficiencye

2 (18.2%)

Lacking language proficiencyf

9 (60.0%)

  

Concerns regarding familyf

6 (40.0%)

  

Complex daily challengesf

4 (26.7%)

  

Grieff

2 (13.3%)

  

Lacking educational backgroundf

2 (13.3%)

Interpreter-related

 

Interpreter-related

 

Precise word-for-word translation f

6 (40.0%)

Lacking word-for-word translation g

6 (60.0%)

Transparencyf

6 (40.0%)

Own therapeutic needsg

4 (40.0%)

Trusting bond with patientf

6 (40.0%)

Relationship with patient too closeg

3 (15.0%)

Caring/likeable interpreterf

6 (40.0%)

Remote interpreters g

3 (15.0%)

Experienced/Trained interpreterf

5 (33.3%)

Interpreters wish to act as co-therapistg

2 (10.0%)

Cultural mediatorf

4 (26.7%)

  

Language mediatorf

3 (20.0%)

  

Remote interpreterf

3 (20.0%)

  

Long-term continuityf

2 (13.3%)

  
  1. aInterviews with code n = 20
  2. bInterviews with code n = 18
  3. cInterviews with code n = 19
  4. dInterviews with code n = 13
  5. eInterviews with code n = 11
  6. fInterviews with code n = 15
  7. gInterviews with code n = 10